https://www.reddit.com/r/confidentlyincorrect/comments/oz5fwf
Anyone tried this ingenious idea?
Anyone tried this ingenious idea?
Ummm, whooosh…Don’t believe everything you read on the internet.
Ships have been extracting energy from headwinds for centuries.This one is true, though, LOL!
That’s pretty cool!This one is true, though, LOL!
So when wind is blowing east to west, and you sail east, this is an illusion? lolIt doesn't exact energy from the head wind.
When wind is east to west, you CANNOT sail directly to the east. But you can go NNE for a mile and SSE for the next, and zigzag back and forth. You would end up going east, but never directly.So when wind is blowing east to west, and you sail east, this is an illusion? lol
I didn't say you could. The energy to go against the direction of the wind, even if it requires zigzagging, is coming from that wind, unless you are thinking maybe it is downhill?When wind is east to west, you CANNOT sail directly to the east.
No patience for video but read about this a while ago. It's not like a sailboat going into a headwind, it's like a sailboat going directly downwind. The boat cannot go faster than the downwind speed, which makes sense, right? Well, this craft can go downwind faster than the actual wind, which doesn't make sense, but works.I didn't say you could. The energy to go against the direction of the wind, even if it requires zigzagging, is coming from that wind, unless you are thinking maybe it is downhill?![]()
Don't get hung up on the direction of travel, or the wind direction. As long as the energy extracted from the wind is greater than the rolling, and aero drag you can move forward.No patience for video but read about this a while ago. It's not like a sailboat going into a headwind, it's like a sailboat going directly downwind. The boat cannot go faster than the downwind speed, which makes sense, right? Well, this craft can go downwind faster than the actual wind, which doesn't make sense, but works.
So you have a propeller powered by wind driving the car. The car gets up to the same speed as the wind, so the propeller sees a wind speed of zero. How do you extract energy from the wind at that point?Don't get hung up on the direction of travel, or the wind direction. As long as the energy extracted from the wind is greater than the rolling, and aero drag you can move forward.
That's the problem with assuming spherical cows (sorry, old physics joke). It turns out that wind speed isn't steady, but varies slightly. If you can extract energy when it varies above, without losing energy when it varies below, you can go "faster" than the wind.So you have a propeller powered by wind driving the car. The car gets up to the same speed as the wind, so the propeller sees a wind speed of zero. How do you extract energy from the wind at that point?
That was the argument of the physics professor that bet $10,000 it wouldn't work. He claimed it was just temporary and the vehicle couldn't sustain a speed higher than the peak wind speed. He lost the bet.That's the problem with assuming spherical cows (sorry, old physics joke). It turns out that wind speed isn't steady, but varies slightly. If you can extract energy when it varies above, without losing energy when it varies below, you can go "faster" than the wind.