This is funny because you're all right.
@TheBlackStig is looking at this and going, "omg this is a slam dunk buyer beware situation and the buyer is a big auction operation, there's literally no foul here nor is there any risk" because he's coming from an industry that did actually bad, shady things that he was forced to witness regularly.
The rest of you are right in that it's totally dishonest at face value on a human level and shouldn't be allowed. If your points are that if
@OkieBolt signed an affidavit, notarized, and submitted it Carmax that they could technically come back and sue you, ok, fine. Would they even do that? Nah.
Also, Archer is great. There, I said it.