plaintiff to show why the impact which caused the dent has not fallen under the cause for denial clause of the warranty declaration
Agreed.
In this case though with the photos provided and the documentation from the dealer there is no where near enough cause for them to deny a warranty claim or to continue to look for other issues. They put it up on a lift, found a small dent in the case and said, look there's your problem without ANY other investigation.
No mention of Cell Voltages, no mention of resistance in the pack, no mention of clearing codes and attempts to charge. They did the absolute bare minimum to get him to go away.
I bought an SVT Contour new in 2000. Put a K&N oiled air filter in the car. It fouled the MAS. Dealer was very kind and replaced the MAS under warranty but told me in no uncertain terms not to use it again or it would not be covered. Known cause, known solution on something they wanted to deal with.
There are not enough Bolts and not enough dealers interested in them for them to have actual trained people. They don't want them coming back. I believe this is what is happening here.
Once we have data on the state of the battery and other actual tests are performed other than a visual inspection my opinion may change.